April 12, 2017

The Blind Faith Argument




Many of America's earliest colonies were political sanctuaries established by Christian Puritans seeking freedom from religious persecution. Those same theological foundations are present in America today and they color our thinking in very destructive ways. There is in American culture a profound tendency to believe the most outrageous delusions. This happens because so many of us are happy to accept abstract logical arguments on blind faith alone, ignoring real world facts that don't fit the logical framework. We learn this thinking in childhood. Children are assumed to be wise in their naivete. We talk fondly of "the wisdom of babes in the wilderness" as if it were something real, solid, and dependable. It's not. Children left alone in wild lands almost never survive more than a few days. Those few that do usually get lucky and find a water supply clean enough that avoiding death by dehydration doesn't bring on death by microorganism.

When I first saw the Tweet above about Ninjas stealing cookies, I quite literally laughed out loud. It was so typical of childish logic. Being a parent, I know from experience that sometimes it is impossible to debate with a child. One of the less pleasant aspects of being a parent are those occasions where the child is lying, and you know the child is lying, but you have no proof. It is very hard in those moments to explain to the child why you know they are lying and why it is important not to lie. If they persist, then they must be disciplined. The purpose of the discipline is to reinforce in the child that deception produces negative consequences. Unfortunately, it is hard to discipline a child just for being a child. It is sometimes difficult to set down hard rules and enforce those rules without explanation until the child is old enough to understand why the rules exist. It sometimes feels impossible to teach children both the importance of obeying rules and the importance of having their own mind, thinking their own thoughts, and making their own decisions. Demanding blind faith in parental authority while discouraging blind faith in favor of realistic thinking is one of the great paradoxes of nurturing children and teaching them to think for themselves.

The American progressive movement has decided that Pres. Donald Trump is a mere puppet of Russian President Vladimir Putin. It does not matter how many facts are presented to refute this belief. There exists a simple, childlike blind faith in the reality of the Trump-Putin collusion, so much so, that it colors their ability to grasp the true significance of real-world events. The day the news broke that Pres. Trump had ordered a missile strike on the Al-Shayrat airbase in retaliation for the use of chemical weapons against Syrian civilians, stories immediately began circulating online that this entire episode, from the chemical attack to the missile strike, was some kind of conspiracy between Trump and Putin to shift attention away from their "obvious" collusion. The simple fact that the only real world evidence of this collusion is Trump's victory over their beloved Hillary Clinton along with a couple of routine meetings between Trump campaign staff and Russian embassy staff does not dissuade them. These were perfectly ordinary meetings, by the way. Senior members of Clinton's campaign staff had a series of identical meetings with the same Russian embassy staff members, but somehow that simple fact has completely escaped the attention of American progressives. When it is pointed out to them, they insist the Clinton campaign staff meetings are routine (or they never happened at all) but the Trump campaign staff meetings are nefarious. How do they know this? They just do. It's "obvious". It is a blind faith logical argument identical to the five year-old claiming that Ninjas stole the cookies.

These two Tweets are identical. The content and context are different, but the logical abstraction is the very same. Something is true simply because "everyone" knows it is true. Facts, reality, the sheer impossibility of their contention, are all irrelevant. They believe in their heart that Trump colluded with Putin to defeat Clinton, therefore, Trump is Putin's puppet and anything that demonstrates otherwise is simply not real. It's "obvious" Ninjas stole the cookies and nobody saw them because nobody ever does. It's "obvious" Trump and Putin colluded together to create the Syrian crisis because if they hadn't, the crisis would never have happened. Random, unrelated logical abstraction has become the foundation for their faith, making it impossible to dissuade them from their delusions.

China-Russia-Iran-North Korea have formed a new, powerful series of military and economic alliances. How far this alliance will carry them is still unclear, but no one in the American left can even see this alliance. They are blind to its existence, and blind to the very dangerous implications it presents. Rather than seeing this new alliance for the dangerous potential it contains, they are focused on their delusional logical construct that has Putin magically controlling the American government through Trump. They cannot see the very real and imminent threat of global thermonuclear war that is hovering on the horizon because they cannot see the alliance that has brought us here. Anyone who points out this very real alliance is labeled a conspiracy theorist because their delusion will not allow for the possibility of its existence! In their delusional thinking, it is supporters of Pres. Trump who cannot see the "obvious" reality they have all blindly accepted as a way of explaining Clinton's loss in a Presidential election that every pundit and pollster expected her to win. Their inability to accept Clinton's defeat has created a huge blindness in half the population, a blindness that the leaders of China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea are happy to exploit. Any effort Pres. Trump takes to thwart this danger will be greeted with derision and claims of "false flags". This is an incredibly dangerous moment in American history. We stand on the verge of a global thermonuclear war because half the people in our country cannot accept the reality of a Trump presidency. This is unprecedented. Not even Pres. Lincoln's adamant and vocal critics entertained this kind of childlike, blind faith in their own worldview. None except John Wilkes Booth and his circle of co-conspirators, that is. But even they in their mad delusions of tyrants and dictators did not assume Pres. Lincoln was acting on behalf of a foreign power.

Raising two sons in a foreign capital taught me to cringe whenever someone in America started prattling on about the importance of being childlike and filled with dreams. This philosophy is highly destructive. The real world destroys anyone and everyone who refuses to acknowledge the dangers it contains. We in the United States of America, partly as a result of our Puritan roots and partly as a result of our comfortable economic hegemony, have made delusional thinking a key cornerstone of our national culture. We call it, "visionary" or "idealistic" or "childlike fascination", but it is none of those things. It is pure delusional thinking and if we cannot break this habit immediately, we will pay the price long before Pres. Trump leaves office. The delusional thinking of half our population empowers both terrorists and nation-states that dream of a world without the United States providing the moral compass that ended fascism. That moral compass is not perfect, nothing ever is, but it has kept the world from self-annihilation for over half a century. If it fails now as a result of these delusions, then not only is America doomed, the world at large is doomed. There will be no one who speaks truth to power if we the American people abandon truth in favor of a comforting delusion.

Earlier, related blog posts:
Putin vs. Clinton, beating the drums of war
The countdown to nuclear war has begun
Book Review: Crisis of Character
Project Veritas reveals Democratic Party tactics
If Hillary becomes President than Syria is America's future
Hillary Clinton, the Second Amendment, the future of America
The facts about Hillary's "experience" are damning enough
Hillary's stance on gun control may have helped Trump win
The world is still on the cusp of global war
A story of two maps



Post a Comment